个人助理生态排名：Muse 第二、Claude Duet 第三
10 月 27 日个人助理生态盘点，按序评 Dots、Instinct、Claude Duet、Meta Muse 等，逐一点出各自招牌能力与短板。
State of the Personal Agents Ecosystem: October 27th, 2026 (Going to go from 5th place to 1st place 🥇) 5) Dots Lots of potential. Voice mode is very good. But VERY early, lacks tons of features, and is more of a research preview with a couple of features, than a real competitor atm. Never count out @OpenAI though Hero Mode: Voice mode with great orchestration. Weaknesses: Expensive and missing tons of features 4) @instinct Honestly, the people that I know that are using Instinct, love Instinct. The harness is very good. it's proactive, and does a great job personalizing its responses to the user. Hero Mode: Multiplayer. One of the few personal agent platforms that offers a true multiplayer experience (e.g. invite instinct into a group chat with your wife, etc) Weakness: the very thing that makes it great, being served in text messages, and not within an app that offers features like artifacts, etc. 3) Claude #duet My sweet Duet. It's fast, its responsive, and proactive. You can feel the power with 5.5 as the backbone, but it's oh so early. Kind of feels like a talented 8th grader playing on the varsity team. Hero mode: Is very fast! Often it will find to-dos / follow ups within a minute of getting those alerts in slack + calendar. Weakness: UX is confusing (when do you use channels vs groups) and features are very limited (no VM control, no secure password store, etc) 2) @Meta @Muse My handsome, Carl. He's a good boy, and he tries really hard. He's just not that smart yet! He's proactive, affordable, has a great UX, and their voice mode actually slaps. Hero Mode: built in artifacts within the app. I pretty much have my agent build me any kind of app I want to use. Also, access to their SDK! Weakness: It's model (Spark + wonder) is generally slow, doesn't multitask well, wouldn't trust with coding, and is not SOTA. If it used Opus 5.5, it'd be the #1 option... 1) @bot Try and dethrone the king, I dare you. Grok bot is a beautiful blend of power, speed, and versatility. The damn thing just works. It uses the best model for the task (others should take note), has fantastic integration into the ecosystem, has the best VM experience out of all, templates are actually awesome, and if you're a coder, that's awesome too with its cursor integration. Honestly, it's just a bit expensive. But if it's your daily driver at work, like it is for most people that I know, then it's well worth the cost. Hero Mode: SOTA models, Voice mode & a world class VM experience. Weakness: no built in artifacts. They recently launched pages, but that's lame. Let me build my own apps directly within the app to use like Muse. -- Honestly though, they're all good. My advice to you: pick one, and go all in on it. Then once good with that one, find another one that would be good for another area of your life, and go all in on that. Here is my current breakdown: Muse: my personal agent helping me manage my life Grokbot: my work agent, helping me with routine tasks, and constant cloud based work Duet: my super human agent to help me be the best employee I can be. With its quick speed, deep ecosystem support, and opus 5.5m it does really well with my connected tools helping me stay on top of everything. -- What a time to be alive! Have fun and go explore =)