Muse、Dots、Grok Bot 三家个人助理横评
作者按易用性、能力、主动性给 Muse、Dots、Grok Bot 排序:Muse 最好用但不敢托付复杂任务,Dots 最强但慢且干,Grok Bot 快但会编造功能。
Current personal agent ranking: - Muse is the most user-friendly, polished, personable, proactive, and enjoyable to use. It also offers unique features like goals and podcast generation. But I don’t fully trust it with my most complex tasks and research requests, and I really want voice mode. - Dots are the most capable and offer all the benefits of ChatGPT, including the awesome new chat model with intelligent UI, Sites, and custom plugins with extensions. They also integrate into Slack beautifully. But they’re slow, rough around the edges, opaque as to what they’re doing, not as proactive as Muse, and quite dry in terms of personality. - Grok Bot is fast and you can create many bots. Also, you can give bots email addresses, although sending from those addresses requires per-email approval, which limits their utility. But privacy options are weird (no training on your data also means bots can’t send feedback to SpaceXSI on your behalf, for example) and bots hallucinate features that don’t exist. It’s early for me with Grok Bot, though, so we’ll see how my feelings change over time.